Thursday, March 03, 2022

Inflection Points

 I have commented more than once how much I enjoy the good folks at Chant de Depart and their writings: Old AFSarge with his (very good) historical fiction, Juvat with his weekly updates of just life/running an cabin rental business/Wine cruises, Tuna with his occasional very thoughtful reflections, and Beans with a cornucopia of random subjects, some surprisingly deep.  I have said it before, but if you do not follow them, you are missing some fine writing.

This week there was a back to back set of postings that had me thinking:  one, a posting by a long-time comment Pawel Kapersky on the view of the current Russian -Ukrainian conflict from Poland, and the other a daily update in the ongoing series Sarge is posting about early World War II, in this case France just before the invasion.

This two contrasting pieces - one current, one about events 80 years ago - got me to thinking about realizations of the world changing, and how seldom it is a process that we seem to realize is occurring until, looking back, we always realize that it had happened.

It is not just confined to the sort of world shaking events the authors above are writing about: it happens in simple things as well.  The relationship that breaks that one realizes had fallen apart years ago yet no-one commented, the business that failed because it failed to take advantage of technological change and thus doomed itself, the religious organization that eventual fell apart because it made a key decision on a principle of faith that eventually dissolved its purpose for being.  The day you realize you will never regularly drop your children off at school again.

Most of the world and indeed, even ourselves, often do not notice that these moments are slipping by.  We realize it after some point of course, when the divorce paperwork is filed or the business goes out of business or the religious organization simply dissolves.  At that moment, we can look back and clearly see that point at which everything turned to a new direction; the old one simply ended.

I think there is value in coming to understand those moments, a value that our world scarcely places on such things - the world, of course, would simply tell us to be in the moment and follow the river wherever it leads, which of course presumes that the river is going somewhere that we want or need to be.  That is a pretty big assumption which can be more impactful in some cases than others:  knowing that Box store is going out of business in the future may be inconvenient if they have our favorite brand of crackers; knowing that the international political system may be reset has a slightly different impact.

The moments are difficult to catch - if we become caught up with and involved in the system to the point that we are always doing, and not observing and pondering.  History is a help here, from the history of states and how they act to the history of individuals in our lives and how frequently they break relationships and which dating relationship they may be on.  The signs are there for those that can see and think on them.

The benefit of realizing such moments is, I think, threefold.  One is simply that forewarned is forearmed, and to the extent we can see these sorts of changes, the better prepared we can be.  The second is that in knowing them, we are much less surprised of the changes in the situation as we always have a constant sense of awareness (zanshin  in Japanese).

The third, though, is the most important though perhaps the least relevant: it allows us to realize those points of changes and denote them in our mind, for the sake of memory or remembrance.  Knowing when something changed, we can look back before and think of those memories and events not colored by the new outcomes (which may have changed how they are viewed) but rather by the events in the fulness of their time and place in history.

A world that too often seems to value exclusively the stream of progress and future, where visual images and current interpretations come to dominate the way the world is viewed will be a world which, in every sense, no longer can understand how it came to where it was or even why it got there.  And to not know how one arrived at a point makes it all the more difficult to either move forward meaningfully or retrace one's steps.

6 comments:

  1. When I look back at things that went wrong in my life with the power of 20/20 hindsight vision, if I really get to the very moment that triggered it, I would almost always make the same decision I did back then with the information and knowledge I had at the time.

    I guess what I'm saying is that I think it is impossible to look back and think we could have done any better then or look to the present and think we can avoid making mistakes now.

    Take our decision not to close down Ukraine's airspace. The reason for it seems logical and reasoned right now. Doing so might spark a war between ourselves and Russia which wouldn't be good for either of us. But what if 50 years from now it was clearly the wrong decision? We don't have the ability to see in the future. All we can see clearly is the past. So even if we had everything to do all over again, we would probably still make the same decisions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ed, I agree, but everything hinges on your comment "with the information and knowledge I had at the time".

      Speaking only for myself - and purely on personal matters - there are three sorts of decisions I have made: the uniformed (read "stupid"), the informed with the available information, and the informed with all the information. In the case of the second, the information may have been available but I did not know it - or it may have been not available for various reasons. That is why - especially as I have grown older - all the data I can gather matters, not just the data that is presented or easily available.

      Some things, I think, can be foreseen though. Picking up on a thread from today's posting by Sarge, the Versailles treaty of WW I was so punishing to Germany that it was highly likely that something was going to go awry. The Allies learned; after WW II we converted the Axis powers into allies through aid and assistance instead of punishment.

      Delete
  2. I guess I still think a decision with all available information and one with all the information are exactly the same in the context of that particular moment and so we only have two decisions we can make at any given point in time, the uninformed and the informed.

    But I do agree that striving to get all information available before making any decision is a good thing and can only reduce the number of bad decisions we make based off our future hindsight.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Agreed Ed - although I wonder if the difference between two versions of informed - the informed as in "I got an opinion from my brother" and the informed as in "I really researched it" - leads to different decisions.

      Again, thanks for the thought. I appreciated it - so much so in fact, it has become the point of a post tomorrow.

      Delete
  3. This is an excellent post! It's like checking your rearview while driving forward - the wise thing to do, but so many don't.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lady Locust - Thank you so very much for the kind words! I had not thought of than analogy, but that is exactly what it is like. While we are always (in some fashion) moving forward, it is good to be aware of where we are in the larger picture and where we are coming from.

      Delete

Comments are welcome (and necessary, for good conversation). If you could take the time to be kind and not practice profanity, it would be appreciated. Thanks for posting!