One of the unexpected benefits of following Rod Dreher's Substack (even as a free subscriber) is the fact that he is a great consumer of books and as a result, I have received a number of recommendations from him that were just as good as he said. One of things that I think helps with that (beyond just the fact our minds seem to work the same way in a lot of things) is that as a writer, he appreciates great writing and the art of a finely constructed narrative.
One of his most recent recommendations was The Sunset Lands by Julien Gracq.
Julien Gracq was the pen name of Louis Poirer (1910-2007). A teacher of history and geography, he is considered a member of surrealist movement. He served in the French Army and was a prisoner of war during World War II. He wrote a number of novels and at the time of his death, had almost 3500 pages of material that had never been published; his request was that it should not be published until twenty years after his death. The Sunset Lands, is the first book published after his death (2014).
Gracq's writing seems like one long, lyrical flow of words (this work is a translation; the original in French must be equally as amazing). His descriptors give both ambiance and seemingly neither too much nor too little information. His keen eye for setting descriptions almost have to come from having seen natural beauty. His words are neither too florid nor too boring: to read them almost seems effortless. I was pulled through this novel more than feeling I "had" to keep reading.
An example of his writing:
"Winter that year was exceptionally calm and clear; one of those St. Martin Summers that the North sometimes prolongs for weeks on end, leaving the trees in leaf until Christmas; all the magic of the North was in that rather enchanted light that penetrated without brightness and, from ten the morning, condensed the mists into a kind of pale solar pinkness. A bustle of clogs and youthful voices, the very sound of the dawning day, sounded behind the stable, behind the thin partition; it was the children of the village, soon out of bed, who, depending on the first in line, untethered the horses and led them out to drink. The crisp sea air came through the open window - the sand that flowed nightly through the chinks in the windows crunched under our bare feet. Our days were never idle. Here, the work refreshed itself at source; when it repaired a net, filled in a square of marshland, the hand wedded its conquest in profound matrimony."
The whole of the book, without break, has this kind of writing.
Interestingly, The Sunset Lands was never written to conclusion as the outcome of the siege of Roscharta is not revealed. Gracq himself stopped working on the books in the mid 1950's and never really returned to it. Gracq himself said in 1981 "...the book is dead; peace on its ashes. It died because, in attacking it, I didn't choose the right tone." But perhaps the lack of a formal ending is precisely the sort of ending that the story needed: we never know if the The Narrator and his companions survive or if Roscharta (and the Kingdom) is saved or simply disappear (which, if you think about it, reflects realities of the historical narrative for all the unknown stories that occurred and were never recorded).
How would I rate this book?
Well, it depends on what you are looking for. The book deals with a number of themes - a declining civilization disinterested in its own survival, the glories of travel, a sort of coming of age, the triumph and defeat of war. The book can be read for any of those, or simply enjoyed as the exquisite work of writing that it is (It certainly interests me to check out Gracq's other books).
The lack of a formal setting may bother some, as it seems to hint at a time and place but not firmly locate it. And if one's enjoyment is not a sort of languid flow of words and descriptions (although there is action), interest might peter out.
For me, at least, I rate it highly for all of the things I wrote above. I think it is a book that - every time you go back to it - will unfold a little more.
And tonight, perhaps, I will raise a glass to the Commandery of Roscharta, a bastion of civilization that neither wanted nor remembered it, fighting the good fight.






