Sunday, January 12, 2025

A Year of Humility (II): Definitions The First

 As a writer and reader, words not only matter to me but are fascinating to me.  As someone who loves to study foreign languages (if he does not end up speaking them very well), what a language has and does not have for words and concepts and how it expresses those concepts tell one a great deal about the culture and thought processes without a single word about the actual culture and thought processes.

Thus, rather than start from the typical "Here is what the Greek/Hebrew says, this is where it appears, and this is the word we use for it", I would like to reverse the order and start where we are now and work backwards.

Humility, were you to look it up in your red hardback Webster's New World Dictionary, Second College Edition (1982), would be defined as "The state or quality; absence of pride or self assertion".   Were you to go back a page to page 683, you could look up humble:

"Humble:  1.  having or showing a consciousness of one's defects or shortcomings; not proud; not self-assertive; 2.  low in condition, rank, or position; lowly; unpretentious.  Verbal Form (-bled, -bling): 1. to lower in condition, rank, or position; 2 to lower in pride; make modest or humble in mind".

You would also find right below this:

"Synonymy:  humble, in a favorable sense, suggests an unassuming character in which there is an absence of pride and assertiveness (a humble genius) and, unfavorably connotes and almost abject lack of respect."  Words presented as synonyms include lowly (an older equivalent to humble with no unfavorable connotations), meek, and modest.

Finally, the entry would tell you the world entered the English language during the period of Middle English as humilitte, which is derived from Old French and ultimately Latin.

Fair enough.  There are many, many terms in Modern English that we ultimately derive from Latin via Latin directly or as a parting gift from the Norman Conquest.  But it always makes me wonder:  what was the original Old English term.

As an example text going forward for this discussion (and next week's), I will use Luke 14:11:  "For whoever exalts himself will be humbled, and whoever humbles himself will be exalted".

The Old English (from the circa 990 A.D. West Saxon Gospel)  reads:

"For-ðam aelc þem hine up-ahefð byð genyðerud (ond) se þe hine niðereð se beoð up-ahafen."

Literally, "For every one that lifts himself up (up-ahefð) will be brought low/put down (genyðerud) and the one that brings himself low (niðereð), he will be lifted up (ahafen)".

So to the Anglo-Saxon mind, the idea of "humble" was that of being made to lower one's self - whether in physical manner or in social standing.  In a society that valued in its literature and culture warrior prowess and bravery, this must have seemed like a very foreign - and not desirable - concept.

So if the Anglo-Saxons saw being "humble" as lowering one's self (as opposed to lifting one's self up), where did they get that idea from?  Stay tuned for next week, where we reach farther back into (linguistic) history.

11 comments:

  1. Nylon129:43 AM

    Interesting post today TB, having a new religion making humility so important, indeed a foreign concept for those being exposed to it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nylon12, it was not just the Anglo-Saxons. It ran very contrary to Greek and Roman beliefs as well, which made it so revolutionary and difficult for many.

      Delete
  2. Excellent information. I get pretty jazzed when things like this are chased down. Did the Saxons have the idea of service to the country when they were going to battle? Protecting the women and kids? Humility and duty can work together... Interesting.

    You reminded me of a Spanish word I learned... ganar. Basically, to win. But it refers to payment, like a pay check. One day it snapped to me that a culture that sees the pay for work as a crapshoot may not have the same understanding of earning as opposed to being lucky. I'm not sure of the ramifications of that. Living in south Texas.... hmmm...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. STxAR, the concept of duty to one's lord was very established, at least in their heroic literature. I do not know that they would have recognized it as "duty" so much as a need of the time.

      That is an interesting note about the word ganar. Words really do mean things, and how we got them and how they are translated as concepts across languages can make for very interesting thoughts and understandings (as you point out).

      Delete
  3. Waiting to see this one play out . . .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. John, me too. One of those "it sounds like a good idea..." and suddenly you are committed.

      Ah well. Go big or go home - and I am already home...

      Delete
  4. I love seeing the ancient words (and their meanings) and wondering about their roots and relationships to some of our modern words. For example, I'm now wondering if genyðerud and genuflect share roots? Don't feel like you have to spend time on that. Wherever you take this, TB, I'm in!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Becki, language is so very interesting.

      To your second question - no, interestingly enough. Per Webster's, genuflect is pulled directly from the Latin for knee (genu) plus the verb flectere (to bend) - literally "bend the knee". Genyðerud seems to carry more of the idea of making one's self low, in a full body sense. I also do not wonder if genuflect comes to us directly from the Latin of the Catholic church.

      Delete
  5. Language and its history is extremely fascinating. I especially like that you traced it back to the Old English because language is truly a reflection of a cultural mindset. I have to admit that I don't think of assertiveness in regards to humility, but it's an appropriate addition to the definition.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Or maybe I should have written "I don't think of the concept of assertiveness in regards to humility," or "I don't think of non-assertiveness, etc." Would that have been clearer?

      Delete
    2. Leigh, I am not sure that I would have appreciated the difference. Just thinking about the nature of humility is starting to create new questions and thoughts in my mind - all good, but aspects I have likely missed in life.

      Delete

Comments are welcome (and necessary, for good conversation). If you could take the time to be kind and not practice profanity, it would be appreciated. Thanks for posting!