Monday, December 01, 2025

My Annual Commercialism Adventure And Demographics

 As in recent years past, I ventured on out Black Friday.

This is usually not driven directly by any need that I have but rather by a desire to spend time with my family.  As they like to go "hit the bargains" (as the kids say), so I too have learned to (slightly) embrace the day.

To be fair, if one is looking for something that one has already determined that one needs, it is not a bad time to go:  for example, likely I could have gotten two years worth of shoes at a 30% discount (had I needed them).  And I suspect that deals on commonly needed things like socks and underwear could be found at similarly amazing prices.

For the most part, there were no "crowds".  Occasional lines, but nothing like the mass insanity that one used to see at Big Box stores for things like electronics (or maybe such mass hysteria still exists; I have no idea).  People behaved well.

The most crowded place we went was one of the two malls in the greater New Home 2.0 area, one of what is likely my semi-annual visit to them.  Much more crowded of course, although it seemed to me somewhat less full than last year.  

The thing that surprises me as I go to such places, is how similar the sorts of stores are.  We went shoe and clothes shopping - but there are just as many or more shoe and clothes shops in the mall that seem to market slightly different versions of the same thing.  Non-specific clothing and fashion adjacent shops seem, to my eye, fewer and fewer.

This probably says something about us as a culture.  

---

On Saturday, with Na Clann safely returned to New Home, we ventured out into one of the "local neighborhoods" that our nearby urban metropolis has.  This part of the neighborhood had a number of stores in it as well - very high end stores, judging from the cost of the chocolates and leather.  It was a decent mix of clothing, fashion adjacent, non-fashion adjacent, and unusual stores (including a crystal store with a rather amazing collection of taxidermy).  

I say "high end" because most of the places we stopped and looked had no prices on the actual items themselves.  At least one of the chocolate bars The Ravishing Mrs. TB picked up was $45. A Cave Bear Jaw Bone, if you were curious, will run you about $5,000.

It was a very interesting slice of walking and looking, clearly not designed for someone like myself.

---

Yesterday morning in church, the preaching pastor mentioned a survey a local church group had undertaken of the greater New Home 2.0 Urban Area.  It was inclusive of a 25 mile radius around the main urban metropolis, and interviewed businesses, individuals, churches, etc. (or so I was told; I do not have the study on hand).

The shocking thing, both to the initiators and to myself:  a full 50% of the people interviewed anticipated moving away in the next five years.  At a local population of that area of almost 3,000,000, that is not an inconsiderable number.

Of course, not everyone that intends to move actually moves. But the reasons that people might move are apparent.  Local big employers are closing up shop here, and the backfill is not going to be enough to replace those jobs.  The urban metropolis of New Home 2.0 has all of the problems of almost any major urban center at this point, and even from our brief sojourn here, it is clear that nothing effective is being done.  Add to that the cost of doing business here in terms of taxes both business and personal, and relocation begins to make some level of sense.

Sure, people will likely move in as well.  But people moving in need to have jobs to come to, and those jobs - the so-called "good high paying ones" are moving to other locales. 

---

The trajectory of this is, of course, predictable.  The people that are most likely to relocate are those who can relocate, whose job skills are such that they can find a job elsewhere or (like us) are still relatively unattached in terms of roots here.  These are likely - but not always - the jobs that are the highest paying and thus, the ones that many of the businesses that we visited over the course of the weekend most dependent on.

With those paying consumers gone, the remaining consumers will likely not be shopping at the higher end stores (they never do).  Tax receipts will fall, which then will need to be replenished (because no government body seems capable of cutting spending these days) by increasing taxes and fees.  The urban issues, not solved now in days of relative affluency, will surely not be solved under those circumstances.

It does make me wonder what The Weekend After Thanksgiving Commercialism excursions will look like in the future.

9 comments:

  1. I guess I'm as anti black Friday as they come. I have never once stepped foot in a store on that day. I've always instead, gone hiking out in nature. I am richer for that, both psychological and monetarily.

    My greatest fear is that all of those folks in the cities planning on moving out will come out to where I am where we currently have a population of just over 7200 people scattered out around the 491 square miles of our county. I think it is plenty crowded as is.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ed, for many many years I did not go out. Then - especially with Na Clann home less and less or only during the holidays, it becomes another opportunity to spend time with them.

      I would not be overly worried about relocation in your neck of the woods. According to the InterWeb, the Sun Belt and the Southeast are currently preferred destinations.

      Delete
  2. Anonymous9:39 AM

    Warren Bluhm

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Warren Bluhm9:50 AM

      (Whoops! I got ahead of myself.) My main takeaway, I'm afraid, is wondering what the bejeebers anyone would do with a Cave Bear Jaw Bone, except to smile condescendingly and say, "Oh, this little thing? It's Cave Bear Jaw Bone. I got it for only $5,000." And years from now, the heirs would toss it in the dumpster headed for a landfill, not realizing the magnificent treasure they were discarding.

      The largest city I ever worked in has a population of about 100,000. I don't "get" cramming millions of people in concentrated spaces where nature has to claw for survival. I hope the survey shows that it's dawning on more people that we should be trying to work in concert with, rather than trying to conquer, the natural world.

      I wonder if the smaller crowds had anything to do with the political movement that wanted to refrain from shopping for a specific week, which included Black Friday, to send a message to the current administration. What that message is, I'm not quite sure.

      Delete
    2. Warren - I do not know I can disagree with you about the jaw. It is just a disposable income throwaway (as odd as that sounds to me).

      For someone that is not a fan of cities, I have spent the bulk of my life living near them. I have never lived "downtown" or "In the city center" and, given what I see when I go, I have no desire to move there. Sadly, I do not think it is a movement of people wanting to work in concert with the natural world, since every time people move they seem to insist on making it like the place they came from.

      Honestly, it could have been due to some political movement - although given the state of things, that could be either side depending on the party in power. The problem with this sort of thing is, of course, you justify the other side doing exactly the same thing. At some point that impacts the people who work at those places.

      Delete
  3. Nylon129:44 AM

    Been years, maybe a couple of decades, since I ventured into the shopping realm on Black Friday, kept up the tradition this year again. Commercial ventures fail, commercial property taxes fall, residential property taxes rise to make up the deficit and do municipalities even think of reducing their budgets by any amount TB? Asking for a friend.......

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nylon12 - I can say that for targeted purchases, in the past it has not been a bad time to pick things up.

      This year our new local library district, who was facing the end of a five year bond, proposed another one. It was not enough that it was the same about as before; they proposed the new amount at 159% of the original bond. Yes, arguably small change given the scope of things, but the sentiment is telling.

      I predict states without income tax will continue to do well. If any state could figure out a way to fund without property taxes, it would become a pretty desirable location.

      Delete
  4. I ventured out on black Friday but only because it was my regular errand day. I usually go early because there are less people, but it was definitely more crowded. What I found curious was that only certain parts of the store were crowded. The sections I needed to go to were pretty sparse, which was a relief.

    Curious about the survey. I wonder how often most people actually move.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Leigh, in my experience certain stores are very crowded and others less so, so it does not surprise me that this would be true of inter-store as well.

      I am hopeful they release more information on the survey. I suspect a lot of what drives modern moves are 1) Jobs (and the loss or gain of one); and 2) Location (family, different living location, financial reasons, etc.). Certain #1 has been true of us every time.

      Delete

Comments are welcome (and necessary, for good conversation). If you could take the time to be kind and not practice profanity, it would be appreciated. Thanks for posting!