Thursday, July 03, 2025

The Collapse CXCIV: Music

25 November 20XX+1

My Dear Lucilius:

One of the things I miss most is music.

Music is a thing that was ubiquitous in our culture and society of up to two years ago. It followed us almost everywhere: in every retail and commercial location, in the car, in our worship services. Many had listening devices (headphones and so on) that allowed one to listen to music wherever they were; in some cases, one saw people who almost never seemed to disassociate from them.

Now, there is virtually no music to be heard at all. I suspect it stems from two sources.

The first is simply that so much of our music was borrowed in the sense that it was “piped in” to us. We listened to it, the aural history of 2,000 years or more, performed by others. In more modern instances, the very instruments themselves were powered by electricity. If we sang out loud, it was only in particular settings: at church, in a concert, in the car at the top of our lungs. Only rarely did one hear anyone singing alone by themselves.

The second is that so many seem to have lost the interest or ability to play music.

At one time, learning of an instrument was de rigeur a right of passage growing up. Many – myself included – went through the inevitable piano lessons. For others it was recorders in class. Some “advanced” to some form of band or string instruments through middle school and high school, perhaps even into college.

And then for many, it simply stopped.

The reasons are as varied as people. For many, I suspect it was simply the fact that they got busy with the art and practice of living and thirty minutes to an hour a day of practice no longer fit into their schedules. For others, the camaraderie of the band or orchestra was what they enjoyed as much or more than making music remove that as an adult, and the interest quickly waned.

A few persevered of course, making music as a hobby or as a semi-profession. But these were inevitably those that did it out of love of the medium – in the world of the last 30 years, there was little enough money in music for the bulk of those that made it.

Now – I would say “suddenly” but we seem to be a little beyond that now – there is no music at all.

In my visits to others locally, I have seen a few instruments: more than a few guitars, mentions of a trumpet or saxophone which are brought out for inspection when I show any interest, even the odd piano or two. Occasionally there are music books around to go with them, but just as often there are none, just a set of notes or chords that seem to have embedded themselves in the brain.

This loss should not surprise me, of course. Literature contains multiple references to music of Ancient peoples for whom we have nothing but at best scanty notes or descriptions. What did the Romans bawl out in their tavernae? What was the sound of the Greek Paean before the hoplites started marching forward? What songs did the Vikings sing across the seas, or the courtiers of Heian Japan play to each other under the Autumn Moon?

I can hum the songs of my youth, Lucilius, and the soaring ballad chords and guitar riffs of the Power Rock of high school roar loudly - but only in my mind can I now here the actual music as it was played. It is secreted away now, in disks and on drives and other media that are locked down although nothing but dust lies on them.

In any crisis of civilization, the arts often seem the first to go.

Your Obedient Servant, Seneca

11 comments:

  1. It surprises me that in Seneca's experience there are few people who play musical instruments. Or sing. The souls of musicians can rarely be silenced.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Leigh, if I used my own life as a data point, I know many people that used to play musical instruments, but not so much now. Not just those that do it for a semi-living or in a worship team or something like that. People that just play or sing for the joy of doing it.

      Interestingly, the same with vocal music as well. The times in the last 5 years I have heard someone sing out loud that was not myself is almost nil. Part of that is is simply an exhibitionist streak that lives within me, but part of that as well is simply the fact that in the modern work and social environment, music is either piped in or the environment does not encourage singing out loud (or even quietly).

      In a sense, music is made for us; we no longer make it for ourselves.

      Delete
  2. Nylon127:38 AM

    The sudden scramble to find shelter, heat and food.......especially the last, all takes time.....how much time is left to devote to musical instruments? Work songs will probably go on at a guess. Shows how much is dependent upon that miracle worker, electricity.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nylon12, survival does take up the bulk of existence when it is not easy. That said, how many people know the communal work songs of the 19th century and preceding? I know a handful, but that is because of a very specific interest.

      Electricity has impacted us, for good and ill, in all kinds of ways. The fact that things shut down so quickly in its absence should be a warning to the modern world.

      Delete
  3. One factor for this can be pinned on air conditioners. I can remember several points in my life where people sat outside on their porches waiting for the houses to cool off and passed the time by playing music. At the time it didn't catch my attention but the silence of it now does. Everyone now has climate controlled housing and so the music is done out of earshot if it is done at all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ed I'm pretty sure it wasn't the A/C, it was the I don't have to be with other people society we've created.

      The Me, Me, Me era.

      I remember decades ago going to AC supported local music events. Most even encouraged sing alongs.

      Parrot heads used to sing TO Jimmy Buffett as he strums along.

      Folks have been programmed to "Be yourself" and not tolerate others for at least two generations so far.

      Looking at shopping apps that allow folks not to interact even at the grocery store here.

      Delete
    2. Ed, I think the same thing is true of just general neighborliness as well.

      Once upon a time, people used to sit out in the evenings in neighborhoods - partially because the house was warm, but also partially because it was the form of entertainment, visiting and conversing with one's neighbors. The same for the proverbial "Sunday Drive", which happened within my living memory - now, I would scarcely think of just "dropping by" someone's house without checking in to make sure that they do not have plans for the day.

      Delete
    3. Michael - A/C had a part in it, as noted above: when we no longer had to be outside in the heat and humidity, we chose not to be (including myself here: the idea of sitting out in the heat and humidity when there is air conditioning available and it is not a required activity is something I am not likely to do).

      But you are correct in that we seem to do a lot less communal sort of events like concerts now. I am sure there are many reasons for it - cost comes to mind, and for some of us avoiding crowds. True, we also have a wider range of choices, so I am much more likely to "find" my type of music, which may be a smaller crowd or venue as well.

      But it strikes me - as it struck Seneca - that more and more we are presented with such things as music or visual entertainment; it is something that less and less we make ourselves.

      Delete
  4. Anonymous11:31 AM

    A very sad society indeed if music is just left out of our lives. Thanks for broaching this topic in your Collapse tale TB. I have pipped up about this before. I am an acoustic guitar picker and am fallen in with groups of locals who gather regularly to “jam” weekly, monthly, or perform a rehearsed set of music making visits to 14 long term care facilities. We try especially to stay in acoustic realm with exception of an amplified bass.

    I would be devastated to be removed from my music friends. It would be the end of my larger world if that was so …

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. FnB - So good to hear from you!

      I think you are right - but I think most people would only realize it after the fact when the music "died". It has become so much of the background of our lives that we take it for granted.

      Good on you for preserving and sharing your talent!

      Delete
  5. Anonymous11:32 AM

    Above written by Franknbean

    ReplyDelete

Comments are welcome (and necessary, for good conversation). If you could take the time to be kind and not practice profanity, it would be appreciated. Thanks for posting!